Halea
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Aug 12, 2016
- Messages
- 1,132
- Reaction score
- 874
@lewy2 : If your ISP is providing you a private IP through NAT and your Asus router is also NATting your LAN/WiFi traffic then your PBX is getting its outbound traffic double natted.
So, that in itself might explain why your registrations are dropping periodically and probably frequently. With your Asus router and ISP router you probably won't be able to fix the timing issues causing the problem, so your only solution is to eliminate double natting.
By requesting a public IP from your ISP you made the right move, not only for the sms part of the dilemma but also for your dropping calls.
That said, some ISPs which assign private IP addresses to their customers by default and offer to upgrade to public IP on request also do that in very unorthodox ways. So, you might still see some issues.
Your ultimate solution might be to host your pbx on a the cloud, like on a VPS. Then the same VPS could act as your SMS gateway both ways.
If you get your public IP upgraded home network to work properly for your PBX and SMS needs then consider switching your main router to something more robust like a self-built opnsense, or pfsense, or even ipfire router.
All three are vastly superior and more secure than ANY consumer grade router. You could then use the WiFi portion of your existing router as a wireless access point (in bridge mode). Similarly once you have your public IP with your ISP, ensure that your ISP supplied router is in bridge mode and no longer performs NAT locally.
For the silly story; there are still out there ISPs which provide a private IP through the WAN uplink (they use fancy designations as carrier or infrastructure natting) which is further NATted locally by the ISP provided router (resulting in double natting) which creates triple natting to wifi or LAN clients with the addition of a consumer grade wireless router like your Asus.
So, that in itself might explain why your registrations are dropping periodically and probably frequently. With your Asus router and ISP router you probably won't be able to fix the timing issues causing the problem, so your only solution is to eliminate double natting.
By requesting a public IP from your ISP you made the right move, not only for the sms part of the dilemma but also for your dropping calls.
That said, some ISPs which assign private IP addresses to their customers by default and offer to upgrade to public IP on request also do that in very unorthodox ways. So, you might still see some issues.
Your ultimate solution might be to host your pbx on a the cloud, like on a VPS. Then the same VPS could act as your SMS gateway both ways.
If you get your public IP upgraded home network to work properly for your PBX and SMS needs then consider switching your main router to something more robust like a self-built opnsense, or pfsense, or even ipfire router.
All three are vastly superior and more secure than ANY consumer grade router. You could then use the WiFi portion of your existing router as a wireless access point (in bridge mode). Similarly once you have your public IP with your ISP, ensure that your ISP supplied router is in bridge mode and no longer performs NAT locally.
For the silly story; there are still out there ISPs which provide a private IP through the WAN uplink (they use fancy designations as carrier or infrastructure natting) which is further NATted locally by the ISP provided router (resulting in double natting) which creates triple natting to wifi or LAN clients with the addition of a consumer grade wireless router like your Asus.